What should I do if Penn National Insurance says “Your injuries were pre-existing.” after my Carrollton crash?

Insurers like Penn National Insurance often use lines such as “Your injuries were pre-existing.” to stall or minimize claims. Even injuries like pelvic hematoma can be life-changing. In Carrollton, we gather medical proof, challenge delay tactics, and, if needed, push for a settlement reached before trial in 429th Judicial District Court — outcomes in our files include results up to 2.05M.

Do I have to take a low offer or can we fight for a better result?

You never have to accept a lowball. We negotiate hard with insurers, and when needed we move toward a settlement reached before trial in 429th Judicial District Court. Our case histories include results such as 2.3M. The goal is simple: fair compensation for your losses in Carrollton.

The insurance company says my treatment wasn’t necessary — do I have options?

Absolutely. Carriers (e.g., MetLife Auto & Home) often second-guess medical care to cut payouts. For clients such as a passenger with median nerve compression injury, we use treating-physician opinions, imaging, and billing audits to prove care was reasonable and related to the crash.

An adjuster told me “You didn’t provide a recorded statement..” Can a Carrollton personal injury lawyer still help?

Yes. Adjusters regularly say “You didn’t provide a recorded statement.,” even when liability and damages are strong. We document fault with police reports, witnesses, and experts, then negotiate with carriers like Infinity Property & Casualty. If they won’t deal fairly, we prepare for a final trial award rendered by 429th Judicial District Court and pursue full compensation.

Will a gap in my medical care ruin my case in Carrollton?

Not necessarily. Life, work, and delayed onset symptoms happen. We explain the timeline and connect you with appropriate providers. When adjusters say “You waited too long to seek treatment.,” we counter with consistent documentation so the insurer can’t weaponize normal scheduling gaps.

How do I respond if the adjuster claims my injuries were pre-existing?

Even if you had prior issues, the law in Carrollton allows recovery when a crash aggravates a condition. We show the before/after difference with records and expert testimony — critical for injuries like proximal humerus fracture. Don’t accept “There’s insufficient evidence of impact severity.” at face value.

Need a Carrollton,TX Personal Injury Attorney?

Voted the Best Personal Injury Attorney in Carrollton,TX

Proven Victories

$2.8M – TBI Personal Injury
$1.7M – Herniated Discs Personal Injury
$950K – Broken Leg Personal Injury
$175K – Torn Shoulder Personal Injury

Top Legal Awards

5 Star Reviews

★★★★★

99.9% Success Rate

99.9%

Proven Case Success

Only Pay When You Prevail™

Your Victory is Our Priority!

Real Clients. Winning Results.

“Nicholas Testa got me an amazing result that will help my family for years to come. Grateful beyond words — he’s my attorney for life!” Mary Lopez - 2024, T-Bone Vehicle Accident Case.

More Testimonials

Ready for Victory?

Talk with a Top Attorney

Free Case Evaluation

Carrollton is a smaller community located within Collin County. If you’re searching for a Carrollton personal injury lawyer, choose a team that’s nationally recognized and locally trusted. We know how cases are won in Collin County—and we’ve tried and prevailed in matters handled through your local district court.

What we do for Carrollton clients: rapid investigation and evidence preservation, medical documentation and damages modeling, liability analysis under local rules, hard-nosed negotiation with insurers, and courtroom advocacy in your local district court when needed. Our goal is to maximize compensation for medical bills, lost wages, pain and suffering, and future care.

Bottom line: Local insight + courtroom firepower = better outcomes. Talk with a Carrollton personal injury attorney now at (903) 665-2000. Consultations are free and confidential.

Rated 5.0 by Clients Across Collin County, TX

Personal Injury Attorney Most Trusted by Injury Victims in Carrollton

In the courtrooms of Carrollton, few firms are as respected and results-driven as Testa Law Group. Our reputation has been built case by case—helping injury victims overcome the unexpected and fight for the compensation they deserve. We’ve successfully handled claims involving catastrophic injuries, fatal accidents, and complex workplace incidents. Along the way, we’ve earned praise from local judges, gratitude from families, and recognition from legal associations for our tireless advocacy. Many of our clients in Carrollton have shared powerful testimonials about how our team brought them not only justice—but peace of mind. That trust fuels our commitment to every person we serve.

When you hire the Testa Law Group as your Personal Injury Attorney, you're choosing excellence, an attorney respected by peers, and trusted by the people of Carrollton. Let us show you what it means to have relentless legal representation in your corner.

Read Client Reviews | See Case Results

Questions about hiring a local personal injury lawyer in Carrollton

⚖️ What can a personal injury lawyer in Carrollton do for me?
In Carrollton and across Collin County, a personal injury lawyer will; investigate collision hot spots like Dallas North Tollway and secure scene photos, video, and witnesses, order the official crash report from the Sheriff's Office (Address: 4300 Community Avenue, McKinney, TX 75071, and coordinate medical evaluations and records with nearby providers such as Medical City Frisco a Medical Center of Plano Facility, and apply local rules of law to help you win your case.
📝 What should I do right after an injury accident in Carrollton?
Call 911 and request an official report. For records or follow-up, contact the Sheriff's Office (Address: 4300 Community Avenue, McKinney, TX 75071; Get a same-day medical exam at Medical City Frisco a Medical Center of Plano Facility, even if injuries seem minor—documentation matters; document the scene (photos, video, witness names). If it happened near Dallas North Tollway, note the exact location and time, preserve evidence (damaged items, torn clothing) and keep a pain and treatment diary, avoid recorded statements to insurers until you’ve spoken with a personal injury lawyer, flag any local rules that may impact fault or damages (e.g., "a local rule that use hand signals when turning if your bike’s signals are broken or unclear.").

General Personal Injury FAQs — Carrollton

❓What should I do if Penn National Insurance says “Your injuries were pre-existing.” after my Carrollton crash?
Insurers like Penn National Insurance often use lines such as “Your injuries were pre-existing.” to stall or minimize claims. Even injuries like pelvic hematoma can be life-changing. In Carrollton, we gather medical proof, challenge delay tactics, and, if needed, push for a settlement reached before trial in 429th Judicial District Court — outcomes in our files include results up to 2.05M.
❓Do I have to take a low offer or can we fight for a better result?
You never have to accept a lowball. We negotiate hard with insurers, and when needed we move toward a settlement reached before trial in 429th Judicial District Court. Our case histories include results such as 2.3M. The goal is simple: fair compensation for your losses in Carrollton.
❓The insurance company says my treatment wasn’t necessary — do I have options?
Absolutely. Carriers (e.g., MetLife Auto & Home) often second-guess medical care to cut payouts. For clients such as a passenger with median nerve compression injury, we use treating-physician opinions, imaging, and billing audits to prove care was reasonable and related to the crash.
❓An adjuster told me “You didn’t provide a recorded statement..” Can a Carrollton personal injury lawyer still help?
Yes. Adjusters regularly say “You didn’t provide a recorded statement.,” even when liability and damages are strong. We document fault with police reports, witnesses, and experts, then negotiate with carriers like Infinity Property & Casualty. If they won’t deal fairly, we prepare for a final trial award rendered by 429th Judicial District Court and pursue full compensation.
❓Will a gap in my medical care ruin my case in Carrollton?
Not necessarily. Life, work, and delayed onset symptoms happen. We explain the timeline and connect you with appropriate providers. When adjusters say “You waited too long to seek treatment.,” we counter with consistent documentation so the insurer can’t weaponize normal scheduling gaps.
❓How do I respond if the adjuster claims my injuries were pre-existing?
Even if you had prior issues, the law in Carrollton allows recovery when a crash aggravates a condition. We show the before/after difference with records and expert testimony — critical for injuries like proximal humerus fracture. Don’t accept “There’s insufficient evidence of impact severity.” at face value.

Have you been hurt?

Need a Personal Injury Lawyer and Being Injured in Carrollton? We will fight for you!

Searching for a personal injury lawyer in Carrollton? The Testa Law Group represents people hurt in Personal Injury accidents and other serious matters across the region. Our firm is nationally recognized and locally trusted for results in Carrollton courts.

If you were involved in a Personal Injury in Carrollton, the aftermath can be overwhelming—medical treatment, time away from work, and an insurer pressing for quick statements. A dedicated personal injury lawyer can protect your claim from day one and position your case for maximum compensation.

Led by Mr. Nicholas Testa, our team has earned awards and verdicts that reflect relentless advocacy for injured clients in Carrollton. We know the local roads, the adjuster playbook, and how cases move through the courthouse—knowledge that translates into stronger outcomes.

Our Carrollton Personal Injury Attorneys focus on the details that win cases: fast scene investigation, medical documentation, liability analysis, and hard-nosed negotiation. When defendants won’t pay fair value, we’re prepared to take your case before a jury.

With a proven record in catastrophic injury and wrongful death matters, our seasoned Auto Accident Attorneys have successfully represented families throughout Carrollton and nearby communities. We’re known for aggressive tactics with insurance companies and a trial-ready approach that moves cases forward.

Don’t face a Personal Injury in Carrollton alone. Speak with a personal injury lawyer at Testa Law Group today. Your consultation is free, and you pay nothing unless we recover for you.

Our team of Carrollton Personal Injury Attorneys has years of experience securing favorable settlements and verdicts. We pursue every dollar available for medical expenses, lost wages, pain and suffering, and future care arising from a Personal Injury.

The Auto Accident Attorneys at Testa Law Group are accomplished trial attorneys with a local track record and national recognition. We are unapologetically aggressive with insurers—because our clients deserve nothing less.

Contact our Carrollton office intake receptionist now at (903) 665-2000 today for your initial free consultation.

Free Case Consultations

Get Help from an Award-Winning Legal Team

After being injured in a Personal Injury in Carrollton, the stress of recovery and mounting medical bills can be overwhelming. Let a proven Carrollton Personal Injury Attorney at Testa Law Group fight for the compensation you deserve.

Take the first step in asserting your legal rights. Call now and speak directly with a skilled Personal Injury Attorney.

CALL NOW (903) 665-2000

Understanding Personal Injury Accidents in Carrollton

Personal injury accidents can place numerous individuals—including pedestrians, bicyclists, and unsuspecting motorists—in immediate danger when a negligent vehicle driver operates their vehicle unlawfully. In Carrollton, these vehicle accidents can have severe consequences for innocent victims, particularly in the case of Personal Injurys.

Types of Carrollton Personal Injury accident cases we handle include:

So, what causes vehicle accidents in Carrollton?

While modern technology has the potential to save lives, it has also contributed to the rise of distracted driving. Today’s distractions for drivers can range from the classic issue of fiddling with the radio to more contemporary hazards, such as checking social media accounts while behind the wheel.

Some of todays hazards motorists face are:

Texting or talking on a cell phone
Talking to passengers
Using an application on the phone
Using a GPS navigation system or reading a map
Changing the radio station
Looking at signs or other visual distractions
Grooming
Eating or Drinking